A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
If Joanie wrote Warren's speech, Trudeau should fire her. After starting with the assertion "the game is rigged," she missed a great opportunity to explain why. Warren is a schoolmarm by nature. That's her weakness, but it's also her strength, and she should have played to her strength by teaching.
Perhaps Elizabeth Warren's reference to the game being "rigged" was a direct tribute to Joanie and this honourable comic strip. If so, well done, GBT.
The line in Doonesbury Elizabeth Warren's speech that Joanie wrote, about the game being rigged, was in this morning's strip. I just heard real Elizabeth Warren speak the exact line at the Democratic Convention. (On this video it comes just after the 6:00 mark.) I am impressed, but I want to know how you did it.
Joanie, your speech was wonderful and Elizabeth did a great job delivering it. Alex was right: you made history. Congratulations.
The current Straw Poll about Paul Ryan is interesting, but I am concerned that some of the people who say they "never lie" may not be telling the truth.
Salvador Dali, Florence and the Machine (channeling Boudica) and Paul Ryan and the RNC, all on one web page...I had been suffering under a sense of surrealism as I observed the run-up to the conventions but thought perhaps I was engaging in hyperbole. It was nice to have my sense of self reinforced by the conjunction of media on the site. I have been engaged in constant discussion with my very politically minded/active son, who at 18, is appalled by the lies he hears daily. He wonders, as do I, how it is that people will accept as truth those things they know to be untrue. I'm introducing him to Dali.
The Democratically controlled Senate goes three years without preparing or voting on a budget, and the combined House and Senate vote down the proposed Obama budget 485 to 0. I'd say a curse on both their houses.
As a Vietnam Vet I take special interest in PTSD, and the conversation here about dressage and horses prompts me to pass along word about an article that ran in the Seattle Times last March. Veterans at Joint Base Lewis-McCord who are being treated for PTSD have been riding and caring for horses, which apparently has had a very therapeutic effect on many of them. You can read the article here.
I'm no fan of Ann Romney, and certainly not of Mitt or Paul Ryan, but I would like to contribute my two cents. I have a lovely daughter with special needs; she is moderately mentally challenged, mildly autistic, and has an extremely profound auditory processing disorder, plus a bunch of learning disabilities. We are very far from wealthy. She does therapeutic horse riding in Special Olympics and other horse shows -- in which she does dressage, as well as equitation. I'll grant, my daughter's dressage level isn't exactly Olympic quality. We do not own her horse; her coach owns a small stable of therapeutic horses and cares for them deeply, with the help of a lot of volunteers and donations. (And in response to a poster who claimed that dressage is cruel to a horse, the horses where my daughter rides have never been abused in any sense of the word; our coach would be absolutely horrified at anyone treating a horse with anything but love.)
I'm not defending Ms. Romney (and if the horse is that necessary to her physical needs, why did she let it go overseas for an extended trip?), but I would like to say that I've seen what riding has done for a great many people with physical and/or mental needs. It's brought immeasurable joy to my daughter, as well as marked improvement in her balance, physical strength, equilibrium, confidence, and compassion for other living beings. And, as I said, we're not wealthy. Please don't dismiss the sport as being snobby or only for the wealthy.
I wonder if RomneyCare will offer a dressage horse and a garage elevator to everyone who experiences adult-onset MS.
Today's strip about the tax returns is just precious, and so what I love about G.B. Trudeau -- his Americanism!
I don't buy the idea that because Ann Romney got a horse for therapeutic benefit after her M.S. diagnosis, that somehow lessens the implied privelege. When my sister was diagnosed she was advised to take up swimming, as that was considered "cheap therapy." But when you're on a tight budget, the extra bus fare and the cost of a couple of swimsuits and bathing caps and flip-flops for the pool, and the $3 pool fee, can all feel like/actually be insurmountable obstacles. A million dollar horse and a $70,000 medical write-off reek of privilege!
I used to muck stalls, groom horses, clean tack -- any job around the stable I could find just to get the chance to ride for an hour a day. Got my first horse at the age of 35. He was a 20-year-old, free to a good home. It's pretty much the story of thousands of young girls and boys that have a passion for horses. Dressage is a learning tool that helps you to become one with your horse. And yes, it's fun. Don't paint with a broad brush: Dressage people come from all walks of life.
The best description of the equestrian world I know: "A horse is a hole in the stall you throw money into."
Ann Romney doesn't just ride this horse for therapeutic reasons. She owns the horse. How many people in America can afford to own their own horse? And it's an Olympic level competition horse, no less. Sorry, these are not people like you and me.
Training an intelligent mammal to move with an unnatural gait through the use of painful and sometimes dangerous methods is not sport. It is animal cruelty. Therapeutic horseback riding should not be confused with dressage nor used as a justification.
Yes, Ann Romney got involved in horses and dressage because of her dagnosis with MS. Luckily, she never had to worry about health insurance or being able to afford her medications, about how to get to the doctor or having assistance in her home. She is also able to deduct over $70,000 a year in medical expenses for her horse. The vast majority of Americans will never make $70K in a year.
The butch-ness of dressage isn't the issue (dressage is simply what remains today of medieval horseback combat techniques) -- dressage on an Olympic-level horse is the issue. It goes along with the car elevator and the multiple Cadillacs and the core of entitlement and how completely oblivious Romney is of reality for the people he seems to want to govern.