A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
I'm a grownup who has had many of these sonograms because of high-risk pregnancies. I loved seeing the baby, but the transvaginal did affect me after a while -- possibly because it also revealed the many ways I was inadequate. I stopped looking forward to them. I can't imagine how they are experienced by women who've been raped. It's not fair to impose them on anyone.
Applause and thank you. Any woman who has faced the decision of whether to terminate a pregnancy knows it is emotionally wrenching and highly personal. Each woman must make that decision with the help of those she chooses to consult. It is her body and only she (and sometimes the father) is charged with the awesome emotional and legal responsibility to support any live birth that may result. Only she will experience the complex hormones that cause the intense bonding between mother and newborn. I respect those who believe life begins at conception, but I neither understand nor respect their insistence that their religious belief should be imposed on everyone else. Freedom of religion means the right to believe as your conscience dictates and my right to do the same. Religious freedom has no meaning if the religious beliefs of some can be imposed on all!
Wow. I'm very disappointed in your latest strip and in some of the commentary I'm reading in Blowback -- especially from the females. I'm a female in my 40s that has had two (soon three) such sonagrams for medical monitoring purposes (fibroid and polyp). It is not a big deal -- not painful or much more invasive than a pap test -- and certainly not as invasive as an abortion or the process to get pregnant. I'd much rather go through a sonogram than a mammogram. What's the fear, ladies? That you'll actually see a baby about to be murdered? I've seen a sonogram with a coworker's unborn baby sucking its thumb. What's to fear about that? Maybe that you'll develop a conscience? As a female who's had sonograms I know the procedure is not a big deal. You do a disservice to your reading public, and show your ignorance, by indicating otherwise. Obviously some of your readers are equally uninformed about the procedure.
If I hadn't seen Monday night's Rachel Maddow Show, I wouldn't have seen your latest comic strip re: Texas' abortion law or even known about it, since Newsday reprinted an old strip instead and failed to inform its readers that it was doing so or why. I'm outraged, and plan to cancel my subscription in protest.
Thank you so much for taking this on. It is ridiculous that women are being forced to defend our basic right to decide what happens in and to our bodies. If someone else claims they get to make that decision for you, they are de facto claiming ownership of you. Control over fertility allows women to have political and economic power. Threaten that, and all of the gains towards women's equality we've made (it hasn't even been a century since we got the right to vote!) are thrown into question. That there are fifty million people who never got born as a side effect seems like a plus to me, as overpopulation and resource depletion threaten our future. The anti-choice side is so blinded by their irrational attachment to a fictional past that they can't see straight.
I am glad you're taking on the simultaneous absurdity and seriousness of this issue. This is not about whether abortion should be legal or not, or whether abortion is baby-killing. It's not about whether a sonogram is useful (it obviously is in many situations) but whether it is necessary. Doctors and patients are the only ones who should decide what is medically necessary -- certainly not a legislator with no medical training, no context for an individual's situation, and often, no vagina. (And shouldn't we be reducing the number of unnecessary medical procedures anyway, to combat rising health care costs?)
It is a sad state of affairs when a comic strip is one of the few public venues where this topic is being discussed without 'pulling any punches.' Keep up the good work.
Thanks for a strip that was genuinely funny and on point. I'm disappointed in our local paper, The Oregonian, for refusing to run it.
As a 74-year-old woman I commend you for your years of devotion to highlighting just causes in the United States. The current political climate as ramped up by the GOP is a great disappointment to me, my children, and grandchildren, who have worked for equal rights for most of our lives. We realize our power and we will vote the GOP out of our lives. Thank you for all your great work and your excellent sense of humor.
I do not like your strip and never have; however, you do have a point in the latest strip. While I am deeply opposed to baby murder in the form of abortions, I do not think the government should infringe upon the rights of citizens. I think abortions should be illegal for that exact reason. So while I am completely on the other side of the fence and disgusted by almost anything you do, I think you have a point.
Wow. Being from Europe, I had to do a Web search to find out what this week's abortion theme was all about. Subjecting every woman seeking abortion to a humiliating and medically unnecessary procedure for ideological reasons is unbelievably patronizing and downright abusive. What happened to civil rights in Texas? As long as abortion is legal, doctors should decide what procedures are necessary, not legislators. My sympathies to the women of Texas.
When you want the government involved in health care, don't act surprised or outraged when the government gets involved in health care. As an old German proverb puts it, "Your bread I eat, your song I sing."
I am surprised that more Texans have not come out against this government-mandated procedure. Maybe these strips will open people's eyes and mouths. A women's body is a women's body. The choices she makes are hers and hers alone. Government should keep out of the uterus.
You forgot to mention that the middle-aged male state legislator would also be against a health care decision being made by the government -- because that's one definition of "socialism." Love you, man.
Ah, yes, the Scarlet A. I guess we have a long history of stigmatizing the unfortunate among us. Who with any ounce of sanity thinks that sonograms should be required by law? Don't we have doctors to determine whether they are medically necessary? I can't help but think this is similar to the situation in Egypt where women were being given virginity tests after being arrested for protesting in the streets of Cairo.
Over the years I have alternately shaken my fists at you for not seeing my side of things and applauded you for "telling it like it is." My verdict on your latest controversy: keep singing the song in the key you think is best. Dude (and I mean Dude in an awkward, trying to sound hipper than I am way), you are awesome. Keep up the good work. This country needs your voice. Thanks for everything!
Whew, lotta noise from this first strip. I guess it will only get noisier. For all the hellfire coming your way please know that this woman is grateful and thankful for your insight and humor on a lousy law bent on shaming and controling women. The anti-choice faction will never relent. Wish they understood that organizations like Planned Parenthood that give access to birth control stop more abortions than they ever will..
As a mother of two wanted and loved children in Virginia, where they recently passed ultrasound legislation, thank you. I appreciate your guts and your support of keeping the government out of my and my daughters' reproductive business. We teach our children that their private parts are private. When the government forces women to accept whatever touching they mandate and that additionally, we should have to pay for that mandate, I think they should remember that such decisions are not theirs to make, but should be left to the privacy usually enjoyed between a woman and her doctor. Thank you for respecting that privacy.
What about the men involved? It takes two to make a pregnancy. Many times when a woman seeks to terminate it's because the man is being irresponsible or downright demanding that she "get rid of it." But nothing happens to the male. I think the man should be charged with child endangerment.
Thank you for illustrating so succinctly how strong the desire is on the part of the radical right to put women in the U.S. in political burkhas.