A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
And the "leader" is -- just another white guy. Not to be all PC, but there are a lot of women and people of color out there occupying Wall Street and other locations across the US. I don't expect a black, lesbian amputee or anything, but would it have killed the bit to show a woman or maybe silhouette the last panel? Though, come to think of it, he does look a bit like Scott Thomas Olsen, the Iraq war vet injured by cops in Oakland. Carry on.
It is sad that Citizen X was not aware of Marvelous Mark's previous career as student activist Megaphone Mark, otherwise he might have tread more carefully when commenting on the character of yesteryear's protesters. Why I bet Citizen X has never even heard of Rev. Scot Sloan, the fighting priest! On a related note, it is good to know that GBT has not gotten tired of covering and making some jokes about protest movements, even after 40 years of doing so.
I'm not sure how I feel about the kid with the paper bag (except it's a bit funny), and I'm a real supporter of OWS, though not in a position to be living in a park in NYC or anywhere else at present (have other major responsibilities right now). But I do not think any human social movement can exist long without a semblance of a leader, not because the movement will fail, but because human group dynamics tend to produce leaders naturally. It's like a box of rocks -- you shake it and the little ones settle to the bottom, leaving the bigger ones on top. (What? Human Beings are like a box of rocks? Ummm, yeah, sometimes.)
As one of the last members of the baby boom generation, I accept the "clown" appellation on behalf of myself and my peers. It happened Abbie Hoffman and I had the same parole officer, at the same time and within 15 miles of each other. My parole officer and others in the region found the man to have an overblown sense of ego and self-importance. I'll also note that my generation is the one that introduced the concept of "greed is good," and went about trashing both our children's upbringing and their national inheritance. Sorry, kids. If you have me cremated and flush the cremains, I'll only feel bad for jamming up your toilet.
I'm enjoying the strips on OWS. Occupy London seems to be far more mysterious than anything in the US. Here the movement is camped out at St Paul's cathederal which has had to close to the public for alleged health and safety reasons until the camp is disbanded. Now accusations are arising that very few of the occupy movement are actually on site overnight and that most are going home rather than camp on concrete. The occupiers are alleging that the thermal imaging evidence of empty tents is made up. It's turning into a conspiracy theorist's dream and the original reason is totally forgotten. We Brits -- can't even organise a decent protest!
Whoa, there, GBT. I resent the baby boomers as much as anyone else of my Generation ("Generation X"). But "clowns" is harsh. I don't think people like Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin and so forth were "clowns," although they were certainly power-tripping egotists. Honestly, as I've gotten older I've come to understand the Boomers better and to resent them less: they were trying to make the changes they felt were necessary in the world, by the means they felt they had available. They were trying to brighten the corner where they were, so to speak, much like the OWS folks. They did what they felt was right, given the data they had and the situation they were in -- just like the OWS folks. My biggest issue with the OWS folks is actually the media treatment -- particularly the patronizing "too cool for school" snark of the newspapers and news websites.
What? Doonesbury has revealed a leader to the Leaderless OWS and thus anointed him! It will be a lot of weight on his shoulders, Garry. Will he be rejected at Occupy for this? I fear the worst.
You are so right! No one wants to be Leader of OWS because we have all seen what happens to Leaders that the US government doesn't like. Here is an idea for OWS. Take a Nobody, like myself, with average intelligence and speaking ability, and above-average naivete. Give him a new name and make some changes to his physical appearance. Let him lead. Then, when Fox News finally figures out who he is, find a new Nobody to lead. It could work.
Marvelous Mark seems to be showing his age much more so than his contemporaries, like Mike and B.D. I hope he's not ill.
I've been a fan of GBT's use of icons for a few decades now, but his use of a paper bag for the (non)leader of OWS? Iconic icon!
One of the most exciting movements to arise in years, giving cause for optimism, and GBT represents Occupy with a guy wearing a bag over his head? Not funny.
Toggle is not the only one who has to deal with his PTSD. I expect to see him in Elias' support group soon, but living with a trauma survivor is tough on those who love them. I recommend that Alex have a talk with Boopsie, the savvy, experienced Army wife.
J.J. you were ahead of your time.
Both sons have served (I myself am a Vet of the WAC), both were in Iraq at the same time and the youngest has also been to AfPak; looks like he's headed back -- I could see this coming from a mile away. It's seriously painful to see folks think Leo's reaction was going to be politically motivated vs. what it truly turned out to be. We are the other 1% -- those that fight these damnable wars and their families that support them and suffer their deployments. GBT/Doonesbury is my support group. We live out in the middle of nowhere. Don't get me wrong, farm critters are good listeners, and sometimes that's all it takes. But I sure do cherish these oddly human contacts I get from being a daily reader. Thank you.
Thank you so much for covering PTSD and TBI with Toggle and B.D. I work at the VA and have seen how PTSD has burdened our soldiers and their families -- the ones from these G*d d*mned current wars, and those who've had it for over 40 years and are just now seeking help. (Most of the worse off ones from Vietnam are already dead of course.) Please keep reminding folks who seem to have forgotten about these wars that it is taking a real, tragic toll on this generation; and remind all that (sadly) the VA is the expert, with way too much experience, on treating PTSD.
B.D.'s words -- "It's game over - the rich won!" -- capture two big points; for the rich it's just a game like Monopoly, and in Monopoly no-one plays to the very end. When one player gets, let's say, 84% of the total property and money we congratulate them and end the game, everyone puts their money back in (as B.D. suggests) and we start again. The rich player then starts crying like a kid: "But I haven't got all the money yet! Let's go around a few more times. Please, you have to, or else I won't play again. Please, I own this game, etc, etc." Go B.D. End the game.
I shudder to think how many people will read today's strip and say "That's what I'm saying. That's why I'm not out in the street. I would if I could." This could be our last chance.
Leo's PTSD must be severe -- he never was in Kandahar. His service and his brain injury were in Iraq.
Like many servicemembers, Toggle has served multiple deployments. He got blown up in Iraq, but had an earlier tour in Afghanistan.
If Leo's story doesn't touch the nation's heart, there is no heart.