A clean, well-lit place to vent

Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.

Nick | Yuba City, CA | May 31, 2012

I think Mel would be a great wake-up call for Jeff. Her 'tude and his fantasy-world -- what a great combination. To see Jeff finally waking up to responsability; Mel would certainly get him to grow up and maybe even achieve his goal, whatever that might be...

Seven | Alexandria, VA | May 31, 2012

Another cosmic strip today. Had we known what point guards and Goth were in the 70s, I could have been Mel. I too knew my way to the vice principal's office. Not surprisingly, that started in the fourth grade. (Hey, Mr. Doyle!)

Dr. Bob | Fairfax, VA | May 30, 2012

I've been a fan of Doonesbury for years, but it rarely makes me laugh out loud. Tuesday's strip did. Perfect, Garry!

D. Taylor | San Luis Obispo, CA | May 30, 2012

I really like Mel & Roz -- they seem like the 'Mike & Mark' of the new millennium. They're strong, likeable people, and I look forward to hearing more about their lives.

Maryhelen Posey | Calgary, CANADA | May 30, 2012

Re HITTING ON A GIRL: This is Mel's gentle reminder to her father that if his stereotype were accurate, all lesbians would instantly know that she wasn't one of them. This is a father/daughter pair who talk to each other a lot -- and effectively. They don't reach a meeting of the minds exactly, but each knows where the gaps are, and they have shorthand reminders of past discussions. Nice to see them not just talking past each other.

Tina | Lexington, KY | May 30, 2012

Re Roz. It's nit-picky I know, but:  "Hair will not fall over the eyebrows or extend below the bottom edge of the collar at any time during normal activity or when standing in formation. Long hair that falls naturally below the bottom edge of the collar, to include braids, will be neatly and inconspicuously fastened or pinned, so no free-hanging hair is visible."

Just Another Specialist | Socorro, NM | May 30, 2012

There's a flashback -- kids will ask the darndest things. At an elementary school in El Paso, (fortunately) before either of my two OIF tours, third-graders weren't interested in hearing about anything except whether or not I had ever killed anyone. Admittedly, this was the first summer of the war (2003) and imagery was rampant. Still...

As for Roz's hair -- above the collar, please! I remember what I had to go through (even overseas) to keep my hair from attracting negative attention, and it keeps distracting me to see her hair that way. I'm not saying the crazy buns people stuffed under their miche helmets in Iraq were much better (how are you going to get that pro-mask on if there's an NBC attack, soldier?) but it's more realistic.

Seven | Alexandria, VA | May 30, 2012

Love today's strip, but Roz needs to get her hair up to conform to regulation. Ponytails are only allowed when wearing the PT uniform. Sigh...

Editor's Note:

 PT = Physical Training

El Tea | Ramstein, GERMANY | May 29, 2012

If Roz has almost eight years and she's a Specialist, she may find herself out on the street unless she makes SGT very soon. Even so, with the cutbacks looming, she and Mel may both be out!

Alan Richtmyer | Brooklyn, NY | May 29, 2012

I really appreciate your portrayal of the enduring friendship of Mel and Roz. May Mel's father come to fully appreciate it as well.

Gordie | Fresno, CA | May 29, 2012

What a treat to see the strip featuring down home patriotic, straight up (especially Mel) complex-free American folks! The world can't get enough if them these days.

Fred | Bristol, WI | May 29, 2012

I hadn't actually thought about it until I saw today's strip, but it's been just over 20 years since I was discharged from the USAF for being bisexual. At the time, I sure didn't think I'd actually see the changes I've seen in a short two decades. This leaves me hopeful for yet more positive changes! Thank you for bringing these happy thoughts to my day.

Alan Richtmyer | Brooklyn, NY | May 29, 2012

Today's strip could be subtitled "Don't ask, tell!"

Gemma | Ljubljana, SLOVENIA | May 29, 2012

Since when does having long hair keep lesbians from hitting on a girl?! Maybe I just speak for myself, but we do love any kind of hair -- especially if there's a brain under it.

Al, 1st Inf RVN '68 | North Eastham, MA | May 28, 2012

Welcome home, Melissa and Roz. A job well done.

Catherine | Fayetteville, AR | May 28, 2012

Today's strip brings up a point that confuses me. Were Mel driving with a guy, would Dad worry if the guy hit on her? Why is being hit on by the same sex any more/less annoying or complimentary?

Peter | Holliston, MA | May 27, 2012

Good on ya, B.D.! And just in time for Memorial Day, too.

Fullervi | St. John, US VIRGIN ISLANDS | May 27, 2012

As a veteran, mercifully spared combat over my 20+ year Navy service, I truly appreciate your consistent support of all veterans and helping to keep the public aware of important issues that politicians would seem to rather let lie, undisturbed. Thank You!


John Sea | Dharamsala, INDIA | May 27, 2012

Awesome Mastery of Art demonstration: The last frame of today's strip -- B.D.'s slump into lightbulb-changing attitude. The dramatic change from frame one to frame last was beyond it! Thanks for the creative inspiration, and thanks for all the years.

Judy Gilbert | Rio Vista, CA | May 27, 2012

Glad to see you back with B.D. and the V.A. Center. Hope you stay with it a while. People need to be reminded. It’s not like WWII (when I was growing up), when everyone knew someone who was in it or had been in it, whether it was a father, brother, spouse, son, neighbor or other relative. Now we all say we support our troops, but what do we do to show we mean it?