A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
Those not so charmed by Alex fail to see that her narcissism is rather limited to some childish outbursts of grandiose fantasy. She's smart; sooner or later she comes to realization. When push comes to shove she is sensitive, giving and considerate of others. Her mother is another story. Real narcissists never let up; they live, eat and breathe only for themselves. Alex is the child of such. Her story is a classic right out of Alice Miller's Drama of the Gifted Child.
Alex is grieving, isn't she. The conversation about her forthcoming wedding is taking place immediately after her grandmother's funeral. In her grief she's articulating, as a grandiose fantasy, her own sweetest dream. Just cos the bad bad thing has happened doesn't mean that good things aren't still to come, is what I read her as saying. In her narcissistic way she's offering comfort to her father. Does anyone know how to lobby the Nobel Committee? Shall we promote GBT for the Literature Prize or the Peace Prize? Genius, man. And a million thanks...
The artwork in Doonesbury is becoming more sophisticated all the time. The first three panels in today's strip have a lot of movement in them, especially Alex pulling on her coat. I've never seen that angle/action in the strip before.
I can't say that Alex is my most beloved character, though she is great. And Toggle really tugs at my heart; the two of them together, though totally mismatched and probably ill-fated, are so endearing. Give me B.D. any day. Insufferable as he is, he has, in my opinion, grown the most over the years. When he removed his helmet I nearly fainted -- a classic moment. Brian Dowling must be proud.
I, for one, am not charmed by Alex. I know people like her -- narcissistic, entitled, grandiose -- and they're not funny. I wouldn't mind if Leo turned her down. Maybe she and Jeff should get together.
I hate to bring this up, but am I the only one that doesn't buy the Alex/Leo storyline? First off, I think GBT is wrong about his own character. She's not narcissistic, just a bit Aspergers-y, like so many brilliant nerds. But also, I just don't buy it that she would be interested in Leo in the first place. I feel like GBT gave her to Leo as a kind of a prize, because he deserves an awesome girlfriend. But Alex deserves an awesome relationship too, which means someone she can talk to about the stuff that really interests her. Please, GBT, don't falisify the storyline of the math/science/computer genius, just because you are presently more interested in war veterans.
I feel great empathy for what Toggle (Leo) is about to go through. After 25 years, I'm still not sure I know how I happened to be married yet. Crafty creatures, these women. Crafty.
This week's storyline is a riot. I always love Mike's antagonistic attitude toward his ex, but today's "Are you on drugs?" retort has to be the best yet! Then to have Alex raise the snark further by suggesting J.J. could use the money just stamped this one an indelible classic. The strip can poke fun at politics with the best of them, but it's multi-level character interactions like these that places Trudeau on a plateau all his own.
Thank you for today's Flashback strip. I want a t-shirt that reads, "My Chinese hosts can go suck eggs."
Alex narcissistic? I saw GBT on Charlie Rose last night, and that's what he called her, adding, "like her mother." Well, okay, I can see the self-absorption. But what is obnoxious in the mother is positively charming in the daughter. GBT was right: Alex has become the central character of the strip. What he didn't add is that she is also the most beloved. Am I right, fellow readers?
What perfect timing for today's Flashback to my favorite Ambassador Duke understatement ("I'm sure my Chinese hosts would be saddened to see U.S. gunboats steaming up the Yangtze as I would be.") on the day after the arrival of Chinese President Hu Jintao in the United States for a public relations tour. Maybe they'll serve eggs for him to suck at the upcoming State Dinner.
I sense disaster incoming in the strips about Alex's marriage. Please don't break our hearts (once again)!
What is up with Alex turning into a psycho biatch like her mother? She used to be cool, now I'm afraid Leo is going to get the J.J. treatment. Leo! Run! Run away! She is crazy!
My husband gave me your wonderful, ten pound (we weighed it) book for Christmas, and I just finished it. What a terrific collection! I loved going back in Doonesbury history, and I found the pages of information and background fascinating. Thanks!
I'm enjoying Alex's announcement -- particularly the part about "He doesn't know it yet..." The real question is just how much Alex knows about what he knows. Might be a surprise there for her, but odds are it may be a long time before she discovers this little fact. After all, Toggle's track record speaks for itself and he's shown interesting degrees of subtlety already.
I sympathize with the girl totally. I too am getting married. To Natalie Portman.
Goodbye, Daisy. Rest in peace. We'll miss you.
Ah, you've done it again. How do you manage to pierce the heart with this comic strip?! And I love that you give Alex all the best; she must be daddy's little girl, eh? I've been here for 30 years, and when she graduated from MIT... Well, there it is. Crazy, but there it is. Live forever, mate.
This is a timely sequence on funerals, given what just happened in Tucson. Relevant in how it shows that memorials all too often become about politics and the grievances of those left behind, rather than a celebration of those who've passed.
Today's strip: words out of my mouth. At my mother's funeral, one of her friends went on and on about how sweet and thoughtful and kind my mother was. My jaw was dropped so low, all I could say was, "Really?"