A clean, well-lit place to vent
Please feel free to contribute to this frequently-updated forum, which posts selected commentary on our favorite comic strip. If you’d like your critique to be posted, please note that civility, if not approbation, counts. Click here to submit a comment.
GBT's Louisiana high school biology class strip was brilliant. With just a few well-chosen strokes of the pen, he punctures the absurdity of the "Creation Science" / "Teach the Controversy" movements and similar thinly-cloaked, Bible-based attacks on science. This strip should be required reading for students in all such benighted jurisdictions who are forced to waste their time on such claptrap.
I find it appalling that you mock Christianity and creation in your comic strip. Whether it is your belief or not that the world was created by God, your mocking of creation was tacky and downright rude. I feel sorry for you and your narrow-minded opinion.
After all these years, we finally get a funny Doonesbury. Today's strip was hilarious. The line "the evidence massively supports a theory of evolution" was pretty funny. I mean, what logical person would actually believe that Everything evolved from Nothing? It's not possible. At least with a deity, there is a possibility of it happening. The "theory" of evolution is as crazy as the Big Bang "theory." There was nothing and then Bang there was something. Sure, if you say so. Keep that comedy coming.
I think today’s strip does a great job of showing a serious problem in our education system. Several semesters ago I was fortunate to have a science class with a teacher who presented a fairly unbiased explanation of the arguments from the fields of mathematics and biology for intelligent design. He also presented some common counter-arguments. The teacher explained what criteria a theory must meet to be considered a scientific theory and let us decide for ourselves whether intelligent design theory is scientific or not. It was a great learning experience, and I’m so sad to see that, as the strip illustrates, many children are not getting the chance to learn what I learned.
I taught physics and chemistry in a high school, and am of the Southern Baptist persuasion. Darwin's theory of evolution is certainly a logical explanation of how we got here; Genesis Chapter One is certainly allegory. However, evolution can not be tested using the scientific method, and if you consider the cosmology behind the "Big Bang," there is always that question, "Well what was there before that?" Science will never come up with a statement as clear and ringing as "In the beginning there was a void on the face of the deep." In truth, no one can explain how the universe, or our humble species, came into being with any certainty.
You are misinformed. There is much scientific evidence supporting the creation model and the biblical scenario. Have you ever thought about how fossils came into being? It was not over thousands of years, but due to swift and complete covering, encapsulating the animal in earth. Otherwise it would be eaten by other animals or deteriorate rapidly back to dust within a few years. Fossils are most likely the result of rapid covering as in Noah's worldwide flood. There are many contradictions to the evolutionary model if you take the time to be informed.
In today's strip the teacher figure states that evolution is a proven fact in biology. This conclusion is not supported by a study of the facts. No one has ever seen, nor documented, a cat and dog mating to produce a "cog" or a "dat." A tabby and a lion can mate and produce a cougar, but they are all cats. Small, simple organisms are more complex than the HVAC system in the Pentagon. I used to believe evolution, as you, but then I studied to refute the bible believers. Surprisingly, the more I studied, the more I found that they were right. By the way, Noah did take dinosaurs on the ark.
Today's strip is great. So much said in so little space -- better than my own post on the Clergy Letter Project. Yes, I'm a Christian, a retired Lutheran pastor who can't believe this creationist/"intelligent design" nonsense still has credibility among the credulous.
I find it interesting that your teacher fails to point out in the "overwhelming scientific evidence" that it's his own religious belief that nothing exploded into everything, and given enough time anything can happen. Not to mention the fact that none of these scientists can explain how chemicals combined to form a living reproducing organism, nor can they explain how the Earth appears to be the only planet capable of supporting life out of the billions contemplated. Fortunately God believes in you even if you don't believe in Him.
I have lived in Louisiana my entire life (66 years). After reading your strip today in the comic section of the local paper, I have only one thing to say to you. Thank you.
How appropriate. Here's today's entry from the Writer's Almanac:
"On this date in 1925, the Scopes 'Monkey Trial' began in Dayton, Tennessee. In March of that year, the state had declared that it was unlawful 'to teach any theory that denies the story of divine creation as taught by the Bible and to teach instead that man was descended from a lower order of animals.' The American Civil Liberties Union set out to find a teacher who would be willing to challenge the law. Eventually, they found 24-year-old high school biology teacher John T. Scopes; he hadn't actually taught evolution, but he had assigned readings on the subject while filling in as a substitute, and that was good enough. Clarence Darrow represented the defendant, and William Jennings Bryan prosecuted. Columnist H.L. Mencken covered the trial, which ran for 11 days. The judge stipulated that neither the constitutionality of the law nor the validity of the theory of evolution could be debated in the court; the only issue to be determined was whether or not Scopes had broken the law. The jury ruled that he had, and he was fined $100."
I wanted to comment on your Sunday comic Doomesbury taking a hit at Christians. Then when I visited your home page I realized you are too far gone. I truly feel sorry for you.
I saw your "funny" in the Sunday paper. Not so funny, or clever. Since the 1960s, the liberals and the (renamed) progressives have worked very hard at eroding Christianity and the Bible. Judging by the number of Christian radio stations, churches and believers world-wide, you continue to fail. Look around and see what you (collectively) have birthed; Godlessness, shattered families, drugs, hopelessness, suicides, immorality and confusion. I can hardly wait to see what your wisdom will produce next. Please read 1 Corinthians 1:17-19. It applies to you.
Thanks for remembering to mention the other animal Noah forgot. As I understand it, God was not pleased that His unicorn missed the boat.
I've read your strip for years and enjoyed the humor, especially in the early years. But I've always been a bit bothered by how one-sided the criticism is. It would be better if you made fun of both sides. I was completely offended by your strip this morning. It just went too far.
Today's strip is going to annoy the creationists again. Good. Keep it up.
As a scientist and as a spiritual religious person, I thank you for today's succinct summary of the difficulty of teaching and talking about evolution in today's society. When a presidential candidate can claim that the forefathers of our country opposed Darwin, the rhetoric has taken over the argument.
Today's strip shows clearly how massively wrong you are. This alternative theory is supported by no scientific evidence whatsoever. It goes like this: Out of nothing, came everything. It took a couple of billion years, and there's no frame of reference to point to. This is the theory. It sounds stupid to a thinking person. Thanks for letting me vent.
After reading today's strip about science teacher Mr. Stiller's obligatory discussion of the alternative to evolution, it came to me that you are a National Treasure. I thank you for so many years of sanity, truth and fun in Doonesbury, and I hope I live as long as you because I wouldn't want to miss a single one.
Re. today's strip: Only a fool says in his heart 'There is no God.' You have to be an idiot to mock out loud your intelligent creator. Retract quickly for your own good.